You can grab a slice of pizza at Mystic Pizza in downtown Mystic, but a stop at this iconic food joint is about so much more than what you’re putting in your mouth. Rather, it’s a slice of New England charm, served with a side of Hollywood nostalgia. Known for its delicious, hand-tossed pizza and friendly atmosphere, Mystic Pizza has become one of the most iconic places to eat in Mystic, CT. The restaurant gained fame after the release of the 1988 movie Mystic Pizza, starring Julia Roberts, which put this small Connecticut town on the map.
While the film’s storyline was fictional, the inspiration was real, and visitors today can still enjoy the original Mystic Pizza restaurant that started it all. With its casual vibe, great food, and connection to one of the most beloved movies of the 80s, Mystic Pizza CT deserves a spot on your itinerary the next time you’re in town. Between your “Slice of Heaven,” as their famous slogan goes, there are plenty more things to do in Mystic, CT.
Spend an afternoon wandering through downtown Mystic, browsing local boutiques, or picking up a sweet treat from one of the charming bakeries nearby. Winter brings a special kind of magic to the area, with the shops of Olde Mistick Village, lantern lights during Mystic Seaport’s Christmas, and cozy waterfront strolls that create a festive atmosphere. Visitors can explore the Mystic Seaport Museum, stop by the aquarium, or even take a short drive to see the Stonington Lobster Trap Tree. Whether you’re visiting for the food, the history, a touch of romance, or some seasonal charm, there’s always something delightful to discover in Mystic, CT.
When it’s time to unwind, The Whaler’s Inn is one of the best places to stay in downtown Mystic. This historic yet modern boutique hotel sits just a short walk from Mystic Pizza and many of the area’s best restaurants and attractions. With stylish guest rooms, thoughtful amenities, and warm hospitality, it’s easy to see why The Whaler’s Inn is considered the best hotel in downtown Mystic. You’ll enjoy a front-row seat to the same small-town charm that made Mystic Pizza famous. Book your winter getaway to Connecticut’s most charming small town today!
Why Eat at Mystic Pizza in Connecticut
Mystic Pizza is an absolute delight, blending a touch of local New England flavor together with cinematic history. What more could you ask for from a slice of pizza? The original Mystic Pizza restaurant, located right in downtown Mystic, continues to serve the same delicious pies that inspired the Mystic Pizza Movie more than three decades ago. Visitors love the authentic feel of the place, from the vintage movie posters on the walls to the classic New England pizzeria atmosphere. The menu goes well beyond nostalgia, though, and features fresh ingredients, hearty portions, and pizza recipes that have stood the test of time.
By the time Hollywood came knocking, Mystic Pizza had already been serving delicious “Slices of Heaven” to locals for a decade. The pizzeria was discovered by happenstance in the late 1980s by a screenwriter who spent her summer in the area. She loved the charm and hometown feel of Mystic Pizza, CT, and chose it as the inspiration for an upcoming film. Filming took place on location at Mystic Pizza in CT and at other locations around town, catapulting this sleepy but charming little town to fame.
Part of the charm of Mystic Pizza lies in its connection to the town itself. Sitting in the heart of downtown Mystic, it’s the kind of spot where you’ll find locals and tourists mixing happily over a slice of pizza. You can taste why this little corner pizzeria became famous, and why it continues to hold a special place in the hearts of those who visit. From its renowned pizza to hearty grinders, pastas, and fresh salads, Mystic Pizza remains a must-stop destination among downtown Mystic restaurants.
While Mystic Pizza is a star in its own right, there are plenty of other casual and delicious places to eat in Mystic, CT. Some local favorites include:
- Mystic Fish Camp, one of the town’s newest places to eat, is owned and operated by the same team behind The Shipwright’s Daughter. It serves up casual but delicious fish, and sits at the base of the iconic Bascule Bridge.
- For a more elevated meal, don’t miss The Shipwright’s Daughter. It was named one of the top 50 restaurants in the country by The New York Times, and is spearheaded by James Beard Award-winning Chef David Standridge.
- Another newer restaurant in Mystic is Barbary Coast, which features a delicious Mediterranean-inspired menu.
- Bravo Bravo is a modern Italian restaurant in downtown Mystic, offering handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and an impressive wine list.
- Jeremiah’s Restaurant or Tavern are two newly opened Mystic, CT Restaurants. The dining experience is a bit different at each, but both offer globally-inspired menus with plenty of New England flair.
- Want a casual bite to eat in a lively setting? Head to the Jealous Monk in the Olde Mystick Village. It’s the town’s only beer garden and has a great casual menu that will fill you up.
Whether you’re here for the famous Mystic Pizza restaurant or exploring more of what downtown Mystic has to offer, you’ll find that every meal brings you closer to an authentic slice of Mystic, CT.
Where to Stay in Mystic
After savoring a slice of heaven at Mystic Pizza CT or sampling your way through the many downtown Mystic restaurants, there’s no better place to unwind than The Whaler’s Inn. Located right in the heart of downtown Mystic, this top-rated boutique hotel offers the perfect mix of historic charm and modern comfort. Guests love its inviting atmosphere, beautifully designed hotel rooms, and warm hospitality that reflects the spirit of the town itself.
Moreover, our Mystic Hotel places you within walking distance of Mystic Pizza, the waterfront, and the town’s best shops and restaurants. We’re located just across the street from the iconic Bascule Bridge, giving our guests front-row seats to the very best of Mystic, all without having to worry about the hassle of parking in this small and popular town. Convenience isn’t the only reason we continue to rank as one of the best Mystic Hotels, though.
Our hotel’s design pays tribute to Mystic’s maritime heritage while offering a refined and relaxing retreat after a day of sightseeing. Guests can enjoy locally inspired dining at The Shipwright’s Daughter, the inn’s award-winning on-site restaurant, or stroll out the front door to explore the energy of downtown Mystic. It’s the ideal home base for visitors who want to experience the best of the area, from the iconic Mystic Pizza restaurant to the many other things to do in downtown Mystic.
Here, you’ll find everything you need for an unforgettable getaway. With its unbeatable location, comfortable rooms, luxury experiences and enhancements, and genuine hospitality, The Whaler’s Inn is the best hotel in downtown Mystic and the perfect complement to a delicious and memorable Mystic Pizza CT experience. Book your stay today!
