Mystic has long been lauded as a highly sought-after magical culinary destination. When you stay at Whaler’s, you’re in for a treat! There are dozens of world-class restaurants within walking distance, no need to drive.
There are so many incredible eateries to explore ranging from cozy historical settings to five-star gourmet restaurants. Our seafaring location means that freshly caught seafood is always on the menu and the quality is simply unbeatable. Mystic is also home to plenty of acclaimed chefs. They’re passionate about creating innovative dishes packed with delightful flavors. Our community is sure to have something to satisfy everyone’s cravings.
Here for several days? We’ve put together a list of some of our local favorites. The options are endless. You’ll definitely need to stay more than once, to try them all!
Experience International Cuisine
The Shipwright’s Daughter
Did you know that the Best Restaurant in the State is located right here at Whaler’s? The Shipwright’s Daughter celebrates New England’s fresh and flavorful food heritage with a strong focus on sustainability. The team is also dedicated to creating classic New England dishes with a contemporary twist.
Enjoy unique takes on coastal classics in an inviting atmosphere with your sweetheart. The restaurant’s design combines a historic and elegant ode to Mystic’s fishing and maritime roots, with the modern feel of an urban bistro.
We highly recommend saving room for dessert for their dreamy, seasonal pavlovas and decadent flourless chocolate cake. Top off your meal with a nightcap. Raise a toast to your delightful meal with coffee cocktails ranging from classic espresso to a flavorful, unique twist— tiramisu. You can’t go wrong… Be sure to check out their small tasting experience to really expand your palate!
Captain Daniel Packer
Ready to immerse yourself in the rich nautical heritage of our seafaring village? We have the perfect date night for you! Head over to see our friends over at the Captain Daniel Packer Restaurant.
This charming historic restaurant features hearty traditional New England fare and roaring fireplaces to create the ideal ambiance for a romantic outing. Imagine what life was like in 1756 as you dine in this local favorite! Take advantage of our exclusive deal. Head over to our seasonal enhancements page to learn more about this offer!
S&P Oyster
Located just across the street from The Inn, along the banks of The Mystic River, S&P Oyster Company offers traditional New England seafood with a South American flair. Their upper floor provides sweeping scenic views of the Mystic River. It’s a great backdrop to complement your meal and an ideal spot for watching winter sunset stunners.
Red 36
Overlooking the Mystic River, Red 36 is a hidden “seafood-centric” gem tucked away near the marina. The restaurant specializes in fresh seafood, with dishes ranging from classic New England clam chowder to crowd-favorite crab cakes. It even includes an extensive gluten-free menu. Another stunning spot we recommend for sunset lovers!
Via Emilia
Experience Via Emilia in Mystic for some truly delicious and authentic Italian cuisine! This restaurant sets the perfect stage for a romantic night out with its intimate setting. Not only will you find all the classic Italian dishes, but the chefs also prepare some unique and creative recipes for those looking to try something new.
A.J.’s Bistro
An ever-popular bistro, Anothy J.’s offers traditional Italian fare on nearby Holmes Street. The restaurant offers a unique menu of delicious dishes, from Mediterranean-inspired entrées to traditional American fare. The restaurant boasts a rustic interior featuring warm woods and soft lighting. Be sure to toast to a romantic weekend over their delicious espresso martinis.
Samurai Noodle
Samurai Noodle in Mystic, CT is a unique and delicious Japanese-style noodle bar. Here, you can find a variety of unique and flavorful dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
From ramen to udon to yakisoba, they have something for everyone. Their menu also features a range of sides and appetizers, including tempura, gyoza, and seaweed salad. Each dish is prepared with care and served with a smile.
Oyster Club
Oyster Club offers a variety of freshly caught seafood, such as oysters, clams, and mussels, as well as a selection of classic favorites like steak and pasta dishes. The staff is also incredibly friendly and helpful in making sure your dining experience is enjoyable and memorable. Check out their sister restaurant, Port of Call—a nautical-themed cocktail lounge and restaurant… then head below deck to Dive Bar inspired by the bygone days of deep-sea exploration.
Ask our Front Desk Team about the Most Romantic Restaurants in Mystic!
Our 24/7 Front Desk Team is always happy to help our guests find the best restaurants in Downtown Mystic CT! Our friendly and knowledgeable staff can provide recommendations for amazing restaurants in the area, as well as answer any questions you may have. We’re passionate about the Mystic community and take pride in helping guests find the perfect spot to enjoy a meal. We look forward to helping you explore the most romantic restaurants that Downtown Mystic CT has to offer!
